Thursday, January 2, 2020

Brain Drain

After working as an architect in Germany for 3 years, I'm wondering if this is indeed the place that attracts skills and talent. Unquestioningly the country prides itself on a high level of detail, thoroughness in thought and work processes and an enviable work ethic, but work culture aside, does it have what it takes to retain talented individuals?

Gender equality
Many ladies would be relishing in the fact that Germany offers a very generous amount of parental leave. Up to two years for the mothers, in fact. Inasmuch as this is a healthy nod towards building families, there are then subversive repercussions in the working or hiring culture. Women of a certain age and whom have just gotten married would then be at risk of taking this (for the company) unbearably long motherhood leave, leading to this stigma of non-productivity for them. This then adds on to the sexism that goes on in the office - the management is led only by the boys' club.
Coming from Singapore, where motherhood leave is a measly 4 months, women are back in the workforce so quickly that aside from their growing tummies, you'd hardly notice their disappearance. They are ready to take on their work tasks along with their male colleagues, resulting in a much healthier female representation in the office. It could sound cruel, or anti-family, but when parental leave is made to be an Arbeitsgesetzt for all, women are forced to take a step back in their careers. Singapore on the other hand offers a plethora of options for child or infantcare - from the very cost-effective grandparents, to nannies, to more institutionalised childcare centres. Women are basically not forced to be stay-at-home moms by the state.

Race equality
Let's deal with the elephant in the room here. In a many German companies - even companies that claim to have an international presence - you'll find the management to be comprised of middle-aged white German men. This puts me off quite a bit - it becomes a clear statement that it is still a very German company that is not ready for/ is unwilling to have non-German representation in the management. In other words, foreign talent is good for Germany only if it still serves a German board, but it could/ should not be in positions of leadership. Perhaps the office needs to still be lead by a German Führer and they just can't fathom themselves taking suggestions from the Ausländer. It makes you wonder if they've had a superiority complex so deeply imbedded in them that they aren't open to new ideas. Then again, this country is so very conservative that she lives and breathes the motto "if it is not broken, why fix it?". So perhaps it could also be caused by their general conservatism instead.

Taxes
Back in Singapore, the Central Provident Fund (CPF) notoriously steals from the middle-class, hardworking Singaporeans to then be dispersed in pensions many decades later. Unbeknownst to many, the contribution of say 17% is minimal compared to what you have to pay in many other western countries. The welfare system of Germany is so well-designed to leave no one behind that when you are earning your euros, you are obliged to so kindly donate almost half of your salary to this national charity. It is even more painful when you arrive in the country as a lone individual, without dependents, reaping little benefit, yet you are supporting all lives of the unemployed, healthcare of the elderly and education of the young. It truly feels like doing charity, and its hard to make sense out of it because you are already offering your talent and competence, and you have to actually pay (a high percentage of your income) to offer your expertise. It's honestly quite ouch.

So with these themes I honestly wonder how Germany retains her talent. I for one, am not too convinced that it pays off to live here alone without dependents who can enjoy the benefits of having a life here. With such a strong welfare system Germany seeks to attract more consumers than contributors. Naturally, a vicious cycle for the economy.

No comments:

Post a Comment