"A pure functioning meritocracy, like that conjured by Michael Young, would produce a society with growing inequality, but that inequality would come along with a correlated increase in social mobility. As the educational system and business world got better and better at finding inherent merit wherever it lay, you would see the bright kids of the poor boosted to the upper echelons of society, with the untalented progeny of the best and brightest relegated to the bottom of the social pyramid where they belong."
- Christopher Hayes in Twilight of the Elites - America After Meritocracy
Creating a Truly Classless Society
Meritocracy helps to make that glittery dream achievable to most of us, reminding us that "One day, even you can make it." It uncovers the array of equal opportunities for each of us to grab, all within an accessible distance. But what happens is that meritocracy can occur within only a single generation, for once the brilliant ones have gotten to the top, they would either make disperse the rungs of the corporate ladder further so people below have to work harder to get to where they are, or that they will lower their arms to friends and family so that they too can benefit from their newly attained position. What was conjured by Young to break down the classes of the aristocrats, especially if they have kids that just laze around all day having grapes and wine, is now recreating a new class of their own. The brilliant ones enjoy their well-deserved places at the top, and their kids too will be endowed with intensive sessions of extra classes to make sure that they get to hang around with their parents. Everyone wants a step ahead in this ruthless race and every 'artifical' boost, the system of meritocracy begins to crack.
Singapore very much believes in meritocracy. We are as acquainted to the multi-syllable word as we are with the name of our first prime minister. We were taught the concept of meritocracy in order to make us study harder as students and work harder as employees, because the ones with the best ability will be rewarded. It is no wonder then that Singaporean parents are racing to the extra-curricular classrooms where they send their kids to. They will send their children to as many classes as they can afford just so they can get a leg up in the competition. If half the students in the classroom has a leg up, does it mean that we still have a level playing field?
I can't say that this system is not working for us. Educational institutions elsewhere in the region blatantly reserve places for the 'bumiputra' just to make sure that the dominant remains, well, dominant. But it doesn't mean that this isn't happening in Singapore. Parents who know friends who know teachers who know principals are difficult to decline when it comes to appeals. As well as kids from the alumni association - why does it seem wrong to admit a second generation Rafflesian? This is where meritocracy begins to undo itself at its seams. It is not because of the system in itself, but rather because of our human nature. We want to do ourselves good and preserve our spot at the top. If having straight-A-scoring kids will make ourselves do good, we will go to all lengths to achieve it. No parent would ditch their kid in kindergarten without textbooks and say "Now go work your way up through meritocracy."
That being said, while children of the wealthy are aggressively being propelled forward with tutoring sessions that come with exorbitant fees, gifted kids from the middle class families are seen as investments that will grant a lifetime of financial returns past maturity. That is not an over-simplification of two distinct scenarios with the index finger pointed, saying that 'They have it easy.' Well, maybe, kind of. But just imagine, when a rich kid has made it to the top, he has no one else to sustain except himself. The prodigy from the suburban neighbourhood is seen to be that beacon of light that showers you with money if your name appears on the nice list. These kids are brought up to be investments that will, one day, pay off.
Creating a Truly Classless Society
Meritocracy helps to make that glittery dream achievable to most of us, reminding us that "One day, even you can make it." It uncovers the array of equal opportunities for each of us to grab, all within an accessible distance. But what happens is that meritocracy can occur within only a single generation, for once the brilliant ones have gotten to the top, they would either make disperse the rungs of the corporate ladder further so people below have to work harder to get to where they are, or that they will lower their arms to friends and family so that they too can benefit from their newly attained position. What was conjured by Young to break down the classes of the aristocrats, especially if they have kids that just laze around all day having grapes and wine, is now recreating a new class of their own. The brilliant ones enjoy their well-deserved places at the top, and their kids too will be endowed with intensive sessions of extra classes to make sure that they get to hang around with their parents. Everyone wants a step ahead in this ruthless race and every 'artifical' boost, the system of meritocracy begins to crack.
Singapore very much believes in meritocracy. We are as acquainted to the multi-syllable word as we are with the name of our first prime minister. We were taught the concept of meritocracy in order to make us study harder as students and work harder as employees, because the ones with the best ability will be rewarded. It is no wonder then that Singaporean parents are racing to the extra-curricular classrooms where they send their kids to. They will send their children to as many classes as they can afford just so they can get a leg up in the competition. If half the students in the classroom has a leg up, does it mean that we still have a level playing field?
I can't say that this system is not working for us. Educational institutions elsewhere in the region blatantly reserve places for the 'bumiputra' just to make sure that the dominant remains, well, dominant. But it doesn't mean that this isn't happening in Singapore. Parents who know friends who know teachers who know principals are difficult to decline when it comes to appeals. As well as kids from the alumni association - why does it seem wrong to admit a second generation Rafflesian? This is where meritocracy begins to undo itself at its seams. It is not because of the system in itself, but rather because of our human nature. We want to do ourselves good and preserve our spot at the top. If having straight-A-scoring kids will make ourselves do good, we will go to all lengths to achieve it. No parent would ditch their kid in kindergarten without textbooks and say "Now go work your way up through meritocracy."
That being said, while children of the wealthy are aggressively being propelled forward with tutoring sessions that come with exorbitant fees, gifted kids from the middle class families are seen as investments that will grant a lifetime of financial returns past maturity. That is not an over-simplification of two distinct scenarios with the index finger pointed, saying that 'They have it easy.' Well, maybe, kind of. But just imagine, when a rich kid has made it to the top, he has no one else to sustain except himself. The prodigy from the suburban neighbourhood is seen to be that beacon of light that showers you with money if your name appears on the nice list. These kids are brought up to be investments that will, one day, pay off.
No comments:
Post a Comment