Thursday, July 11, 2013

Equality in Meritocracy

The biggest paradox in the Singapore society is for it to claim that All of us are equal before the law, yet We must uphold meritocracy and incorruptibility.
 
Alfian Sa'at truly created a masterpiece of intellectual conundrums on what it means to be a Singaporean. And the most poignant was when the issue was brought up - Singaporeans are too xenophobic. We label everyone else without possession of the pink ID, an FT, as though brandishing them with a red arm band like how they did it many decades ago. We throw them dirty looks when they sit on our buses and occupy our trains and fill it up with strange odours. We always pull out that FT wild card when we are unable to acquire that job, or that university placement, or even that seat on the train. Of course its easy to accuse Singaporeans of being xenophobic, because that is what I opine as well. But there was that alternative point of view that suggests that possibly 'xenophobia' might not be the most apt word to use.
 
'Xenophobia' is derived from two words 'xenos', meaning stranger or foreigner and 'phobos', meaning fear. Now we use the word 'phobia' on other fears as well, arachnophobia, fear of spiders, hydrophobia, fear of water or acrophobia, the fear of heights. These fears are irrational. They cannot be explained because of a certain logic - they just exist in our minds. Singaporeans - our seemingly apalling attitude is not xenophobia because those fears that we have of these foreigners, are compounded by the fact that we cannot do anything about it. Forget democracy, freedom of speech and human rights, one vote every four years do not at all determine political liberty. We have even less say in policies that are passed in the parliament. Each time someone decides to increase the national GDP by a couple more percent and drastic measures have to be taken, all we can do is watch. Watch these white-haired men in white-washed clothes speak in their best Singaporean English slur like we are detached from the discussion altogether. We have less influence or impact on their decisions than an ardent fan cheering for his favorite tennis player in the Wimbledon.
 
This issue isn't unique to Singapore alone. Many 'first-world' countries claim to be the same: a democratic republic. Promising to deliver the best to their people. Maybe we can question ourselves, do we need to exist within a nation-state? Caught up in incessant broils of various parties that demand their rights to the throne. We are just patrons of the show.

Majulah Singapura.

No comments:

Post a Comment